JournalTOCs

Journal for the History of Analytical Philosophy
Number of Followers: 5

This is an Open Access Journal

Open Access journal
ISSN (Print) 2159-0303 - ISSN (Online) 2159-0303
Published by New Prairie Press

[17 journals]

Review of Sanford Shieh, Necessity Lost
- Authors: Roberta Ballarin
  Abstract: ~
  PubDate: 2022-03-30
  DOI: 10.15173/jhap.v10i3.5135
  Issue No: Vol. 10, No. 3 (2022)
Wittgenstein's Reductio
- Authors: Gilad Nir
  Abstract: By means of a reductio argument, Wittgenstein’s Tractatus calls into question the very idea that we can represent logical form. My paper addresses three interrelated questions: first, what conception of logical form is at issue in this argument' Second, whose conception of logic is this argument intended to undermine' And third, what could count as an adequate response to it' I show that the argument construes logical form as the universal, underlying correlation of any representation and the reality it represents. I further show that the argument seeks to undermine core commitments of Frege’s and Russell’s. But the reductio, as I read it, is not intended to establish the falsity of any of their specific assumptions. Rather, its aim is to make manifest the indeterminacies that underlie the language in which these assumptions are framed, and establish the need for a transformation of that language. So understood, Wittgenstein’s argument exemplifies his idea that philosophy is not a theory, but an activity of elucidation. The interpretation I propose bears on one of the central debates in the literature, namely how we should understand Wittgenstein’s contention that his elucidations succeed despite being nonsensical.
  PubDate: 2022-03-30
  DOI: 10.15173/jhap.v10i3.4410
  Issue No: Vol. 10, No. 3 (2022)