HOME > Journal Current TOC
EStAL - European State Aid Law Quarterly
[5 followers] Follow
Subscription journal
ISSN (Print) 1619-5272
Published by Lexxion Verlagsgesellschaft
[12 journals]
[5 followers] Follow ISSN (Print) 1619-5272
Published by Lexxion Verlagsgesellschaft
[12 journals]- Report on the 2012 Autumn Conference of the European State Aid Law Institute
- Abstract: 434 Report on the 2012 Autumn Conference of the European State Aid Law Institute EStAL 2 2013
Report on the 2012 Autumn Conference
of the European State Aid Law Institute
Jonas Lybech Jensen*
The EStALI Autumn Conference was organised in cooperation with the Faculty of Law of Copenhagen
University and took place on 30 November 2012 in the beautiful Alexander Hall situated
in the Danish capital’s city centre.
I. Introduction
As Andreas Bartosch stated dur
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:29:42 +010
- Abstract: 434 Report on the 2012 Autumn Conference of the European State Aid Law Institute EStAL 2 2013
- Book Reviews
- Abstract: Das EU-Beihilferecht – Die Anwendung des EU-Beihilferechts in der Finanzkrise unter juristischökonomischer Betrachtung für die Kreditinstitute
EU State Aid Law – The Application of EU State Aid Law in the Financial
Crisis from a Legal-Economic Perspective for Credit Institutions
By Oliver Michaelis Verlag Dr. Kovacˇ Hamburg 2011, ISBN: 978-3-8300-5498-6, 720 pp., € 138,– Research Handbook on European State Aid Law
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:28:09 +010
- Abstract: Das EU-Beihilferecht – Die Anwendung des EU-Beihilferechts in der Finanzkrise unter juristischökonomischer Betrachtung für die Kreditinstitute
- SES Astra
- Abstract: On 16 July 2012, the Spanish Supreme Court delivered
judgment 4955/20121 which reflects the ex officio
obligation of all national courts to assess and
grant the most suitable interim measures to safeguard
the individual rights of all interested parties,
even when illegal aid has already been paid out and
the projects for which State aid was awarded have
been completely executed. This was the case with
the implementation of the necessary measures for
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:21:12 +010
- Abstract: On 16 July 2012, the Spanish Supreme Court delivered
- Budapest Erőmű Zrt
- Abstract: The setting of this case is located in the highly regulated
energy sector of Hungary, in which most of
the State aid relevant actions took place long before
Hungary’s accession to the European Union.
Inter alia, the case raises complex questions about
the relevant time of assessment, especially with regard
to pre-accession measures and therefore also to
the correct interpretation of Annex IV to the 2004
Act on Accession, as well as the definition of i
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:18:25 +010
- Abstract: The setting of this case is located in the highly regulated
- BNP Paribas
- Abstract: The Court of Justice of the EU (“ECJ” or “Court”),
following an established tradition1, has set aside yet
another judgment of the General Court in relation to
material selectivity of tax measures. In the case at
hand, the judgment concerned a system of fiscal neutrality
for the transfers of assets between companies
put in place by the Italian legislator and a subsequent
“tax realignment” mechanism to adjust the tax value
of the assets to the
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:15:54 +010
- Abstract: The Court of Justice of the EU (“ECJ” or “Court”),
- British Aggregates
- Abstract: The case at issue is the General Court renvoi from the
European Court of Justice (‘ECJ’) British Aggregates
case of 2009.1 This case is the final answer of the
European Courts to the British Aggregates ‘saga’. The
2006 General Court case has raised much criticism,
especially because of the erroneous interpretation of
the concept of material selectivity for eco-tax levies.2
The judgment was appealed to the ECJ which annulled
the General Court jud
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:09:53 +010
- Abstract: The case at issue is the General Court renvoi from the
- FagorBrandt
- Abstract: The judgement of the General Court in the
FagorBrandt case1, 2 (the “Judgement”) relates to the
application for annulment of the European Commission
(the “Commission”) State aid Decision declaring
the compatibility of the restructuring aid of €31 million
by France to FagorBrandt subject to conditions
(the “Decision”).3 The General Court quashed the Decision
on the grounds that the Commission committed
a manifest error when assessing the co
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:06:42 +010
- Abstract: The judgement of the General Court in the
- State Aid and Supply-Side Geographic Market Definition
- Abstract: I. Introduction
The European Commission launched a major initiative
to modernize State aid control,1 and has recently
issued draft guidelines on regional State aid for 2014-
2020 (“Draft Regional Aid Guidelines”).2 The related
communication stated “An effective internal market
requires deployment of . . . competition policy including
State aid control to ensure that the functioning of
that internal market is not distorted by anticompetitive
beha
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:01:20 +010
- Abstract: I. Introduction
- Public Undertakings and Imputability – The Case of DSBFirst
- Abstract: In this article, the issue of impuability to the State of public undertakings’ decision-making is
analysed and discussed in the context of the DSBFirst case. DSBFirst is owned by the independent
public undertaking DSB and the private undertaking FirstGroup plc and won the contracts in
the 2008 Oeresund tender for the provision of passenger transport by railway. From the start,
the services were provided at a loss, and in the end a part of DSBFirst was wound up. In order
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 11:00:01 +010
- Abstract: In this article, the issue of impuability to the State of public undertakings’ decision-making is
- State Aid Policy in the EU Member States
- Abstract: It’s a Different Game They Play
The European Union is almost the only international organisation with a system of State
aid control. The main reasons for the existence of this system are ensuring a level playing
field within the EU internal market, avoiding subsidy races between EU Member States and
preserving economic and social welfare. Despite this EU system of control and a WTO agreement
documenting a wider international consensus to limit State aid, large am
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:58:27 +010
- Abstract: It’s a Different Game They Play
The European Union is almost the only international organisation with a system of State
- The WTO Airbus Dispute: Findings of the Panel and of the Appellate Body
- Abstract: I. Introduction
This article outlines the legal findings rendered by
the panel and by the Appellate Body (AB) in the
WTO Airbus dispute.1 The US launched this case to
probe the WTO-consistency of a number of subsidies
allegedly bestowed by the EU and four of its Member
States – France, Germany, Spain and the United
Kingdom – to Airbus, the European manufacturer
of large civil aircrafts (LCA). Due to the breath of
the US challenge and to the fact-i
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:55:08 +010
- Abstract: I. Introduction
- Observations on the Financial Crisis in Ireland and the Use of the State Aid Rules by the EU ...
- Abstract: I. Introduction
This paper looks at the State Aid regime put in place
by the EU Commission over a relatively short period
in late 2008 and 2009 to respond to the initial and
most virulent phase of the global financial crisis, at
how those rules were applied to financial institutions
across the EU, and in particular to Irish banks
where the impact of the crisis has been most keenly
felt. It commences with a review of the causes of the
crisis. One of th
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:53:56 +010
- Abstract: I. Introduction
- Overview of the Case Law in State Aid Matters: June 2011 to June 2012
- Abstract: I. Introduction
There is something paradoxical about State aid in
times of economic crisis. On the one hand, it is understandable
that Member States of the European Union
seek to help companies in distress and combat rising
unemployment. On the other hand, Member States
need to control public expenditure in order to avoid
further deterioration of their economies and granting
State aid can make things even worse. A coordinated
and targeted approach by
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:51:30 +010
- Abstract: I. Introduction
- Taxes, the Cost of Capital and the Private Investor Principle
- Abstract: I. Introduction
The Court of Justice recently addressed the question
whether the State can convert an amount of tax owed
by company into equity for that company. This possibility
raises a bigger question: can the State can act
as a private investor by using fiscal resources which,
by their very nature, are not available to private investors?
The answers of the Court of Justice to both questions
were in the affirmative. In the EDF case, the
Court uphel
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:48:52 +010
- Abstract: I. Introduction
- News from the Member States
- Abstract:
France Nicole Coutrelis and Sandra Caussanel Germany Christoph Arhold Hungary Aniko Keller Italy Sara Gobbato
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:45:32 +010
- Abstract:
- Blurring at Black and White
- Abstract: EStAL 2 2013 Editorial 233
In early May last year the Commission published a short document on what has since become
known as the SAM, the State Aid Modernization plan. For the many who had expected more
substance to be put into it, these few pages were somewhat disappointing at the time. Almost
one year later, Member States and stakeholders have been provided with a lot more, i.e. proposals
for new Enabling as well as Procedural Regulations, various issue papers on dive
PubDate: Thu, 16 May 2013 10:37:11 +010
- Abstract: EStAL 2 2013 Editorial 233
- News from the Member States
- Abstract:
Austria Birgit Haslinger Belgium Cédric Kaczmarek Bulgaria Iveta Stoycheva and Mariya Papazova Croatia Tatjana Jakovljević Cyprus Michalis Kamperis Finland Ilkka Aalto-Setälä and Heidi Merikalla-Teir
PubDate: Wed, 20 Feb 2013 10:55:28 +010
- Abstract:
- Legal Requirements for the Sale of Land by Public Authorities free of State Aid
- Abstract: I. Introduction
In its recent judgment in C-239/09 regarding a preliminary
ruling under Article 267 TFEU (formerly
Article 234 EC) the ECJ held that national calculation
methods for determining the value of land to
be sold by public authorities allow a sale free of
State aid if these methods provide for a timely
update of prices in order to reflect sharply rising
prices when calculating the market value of publicly
owned land. Apart from this guidance
PubDate: Wed, 17 Aug 2011 15:19:14 +010
- Abstract: I. Introduction
- Commission v Scott – How much freedom for the Commission in “Complex Economic Assessment” ...
- Abstract: On 2 September 2010 the Court of Justice delivered
its judgment in the case C-290/07 P – Commission v
Scott (the “Judgment”).
The Judgment constitutes the most recent
episode in a long saga of litigation before the European
Courts.1 It sets aside a ruling of the General
Court2 which quashed a decision of the European
Commission (“Commission”)3 declaring the sale of
a parcel of land by a French local authority to the
paper manufacturer Scott
PubDate: Fri, 11 Feb 2011 11:03:04 +010
- Abstract: On 2 September 2010 the Court of Justice delivered



